Branches and Roots

Every once in a while you hear of unusually creative friendships. Such friendships have the dual effect on my consciousness of restoring my faith in humanity and sparking my imagination relative to our collective future. I stumbled across a lovely passage which describes one such friendship between Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau in Robert D. Richardon’s Emerson: The Mind on Fire:

A visitor in 1852 named John Albee has left the fullest description of how Emerson and Thoreau got along together in public. Thoreau was already at Emerson’s when Albee arrived. “He was much at home with Emerson: and as he remained through the afternoon and evening, and I left him still at the fire side, he appeared to me to belong in some way to the household.” Emerson continually deferred to Thoreau, Albee recalled, “and seemed to anticipate his views, preparing himself obviously for a quiet laugh at Thoreau’s negative and biting criticism, especially in regard to education and educational institutions.” Albee had come to find out how to get the best kind of education.

Emerson pleaded always for the college; said he himself had entered at fourteen. This aroused the wrath of Thoreau, who would not allow any good to the college course. And here it seemed to me Emerson said things on purpose to draw Thoreau’s fire and to amuse himself. When the curriculum at Cambridge was alluded to, and Emerson casually remarked that most of the branches of learning were taught there, Thoreau seized one of his opportunities and replied “Yes indeed, all the branches and none of the roots.” At this Emerson laughed heartily… in the evening Thoreau devoted himself wholly to the children and the parching of corn by the open fire.

If the friendship provided kindling for the fires of my imagination, Thoreau’s comment was the spark for this upcoming series of posts on the subjects of medicine, art and philosophy. Having worked in the field of medicine for the last twenty years or so, I must say that medicine, like any science provides endless opportunity for exploration and consideration. The branches of medicine are becoming increasingly well-defined and as such are more differentiated from one another than ever before, but I have to wonder if our obsession with the branches has left us out on a limb, metaphorically-speaking, to the point that we’ve forgotten about the roots which support the whole structure.

All systems of medicine are concerned with restoring health at the physical, mental or emotional level, or some combination of the three. The design and interactions of these three levels is incredibly complex and despite our progress in mapping out its various components and their inter-relationships, the unknown significantly outweighs unknown. Our various parts are animated by forces biological, mechanical, chemical and energetic and as a result, the science of medicine is necessarily multi-disciplinary, including but not limited to sciences such as biology, chemistry, biochemistry, anatomy, physiology, physics and more.

More to come…

8 thoughts on “Branches and Roots

  1. Teryl Worster's avatar Teryl Worster

    I love learning!! Thanks for doing all the work findig amazing subjects, authors, poets, etc. It is so very much appreciated!!

    Like

  2. Colin's avatar Colin

    It is great how Thoreau and Emerson knew each other so well, and were able to keep such close company with their varying opinions. It actually seems like Thoreau’s opinions endeared him to Emerson, rather than being an irritant.
    Like any living thing, whether plant or the body of humanity, emphasis of the branches of education and neglect of the root will net you with a dead plant in the end. A single branch doesn’t necessarily have to know what the other branches are doing, but they need to be connected to a root that understands the whole system. That is what we are missing from education, and especially what we are missing from medicine. I think they have been working on having someone who has a position as the coordinator of the medical specialists, but it is far from adequate. That is not the only issue, as the field of medicine is much bigger than just western modern medicine, and the other branches have been neglected here as well. There has to be a central control, both for the micro and the macro aspects of health. The branches have to be reconnected to the roots.

    Like

  3. Lady Leo's avatar Lady Leo

    I’ve always enjoyed reading about the friendships and camaraderie of the Transendentalists. They shared a passion to live their lives governed by their enlightened understanding of it; in an age when societal rules were clearly and narrowly spelled out, and public outrage was vehement when you didn’t. They communed on the level of educating themselves by listening to each others ideas, expanding on them and revisiting each other to share their expanded understanding. I’m eagerly anticipating your thoughts on this subject. Your blog is quite the “Bloomsbury” of 2012 ! Thank you.

    Like

Leave a reply to Steve Ventola Cancel reply