Elmer Wheeler, one of America’s classic salesman, understood well the power of persuasive writing and the importance of asking the right questions. He coined the famous slogan: “Say it with flowers” and was the originator of the maxim: “Don’t sell the steak – sell the sizzle.” One of his most powerful pieces of advice came in the form of a simple suggestion: “Don’t ask if – ask which.”
This last “Wheelerpoint” has been employed successfully in the field of sales for decades (and I’m sure longer as Wheeler probably didn’t invent it, but renamed and repackaged it), but it has also been used as a means of keeping people from truly knowing and understanding themselves. Allow me to explain.
Alternate of choice questions abound in pop psychology. Questions like: “Are you right-brained or left-brained?” or “Are you a heart person or a mind person?” are used by people keen on understanding themselves and those around them, but to me such questions are deceptive and generally unhelpful.
Your heart and mind are not what you are, they are tools you have. As such, both questions above are specious. How can you truthfully answer either question if you are neither? You have both and are probably wired in a way that one is more dominant than the other, but you are neither.
The trouble with believing that these questions are the right questions is that you don’t really get to the core of the issue of identity. And if you don’t really know who you are, how likely is it that your next steps – especially if you intend to work on yourself – are going to be in the right direction?
I’ve noticed over time that people love to weigh these choices and I suspect that the narcissism of small differences has something to do with this fascination. Moreover, at risk of generalizing, it seems that those who finally judge themselves as being “heart” people embark on journeys of narcissistic hedonism while those who side with the “mind” people tend toward narcissistic asceticism. In either case, it’s all about them.
The truth of the matter is that the question of our individuality is, oddly enough, not all about us. Sure we are individual and unique focalizations of the ethereal quality we call “life”, but our identity is not known to us by virtue of introspection, it is made known to us by reason of our expression.
I contend that we as a species will be restricted to a life of supposition and of self-styled imagination until we come to the point where we finally admit to ourselves that it’s not all about us. We are laboring under a pathological narcissism and that self-obsession is preventing us from truly knowing ourselves. And that laboring, dear readers, is in vain.
If you doubt my analysis, look at yourself or look around you. How many adults have a weak sense of self and require constant validation?
This is a chronic illness for which there is a simple remedy: a dose of the truth. The truth is that you are a wonderful and highly specialized focus of creative influence and your opportunity, should you choose to accept it, is to use your heart and mind to magnify that inner reality, to give outer, visible evidence of that inner presence. When you do accept this truth, you no longer make the fallacious statement: “I am what I have.” Instead, you find the voice that allows you to say – as few on earth have – “I am what I am.”
Yeah, sometimes those alternate choice questions are a red herring – through constrained choices, it either fools or distracts from what is really going on. There are many assumptions embedded in our culture that we’ve simply accepted without too much questioning. It all helps to shape our identity and the more we blindly accept the various roles that come with them, the more artificial becomes out sense of self.
Identity can be something much deeper, something without the overlays of customs which allows a full freedom of being. Assumptions do need to be questioned while thinking outside the box; it can be a bit tricky without a balanced temperament because you can easily slip into rebellion which is yet another distraction. Only wisdom and peace can allow this natural enfolding as the historical record exemplifies with the many examples of courageous people who have successfully made the trek.
LikeLike
We are faced with unburdening ourselves from these alternate-choice questions daily; they limit many without them even knowing it. The great thing is that we do not have to break their chains one by one. Simply following the advice you put forth here, that we can discover our inner selves and inner value by learning to use who we are and what we have available now.
As you do this, you begin to discover that your true worth is deeper and fuller than you had imagined. With this discovery comes a greater capacity to express it, and the cycle continues.
It is my greatest hope that enough people can one day see the beauty of this approach to make the “alternate choice” questions that have no right answers a thing of the past.
LikeLike
Your words have an eternal ring to them. Thanks for your clarification.
LikeLike
I’ve often thought upon hearing those declarations that they really are a waste of time. Actions speak so loudly that most will disregard what you think of yourself. I agree that our unique selves will be discovered as we live our lives. What we intrinsically are can only be realized as it is actualized. I loved your clear description of this simple point. It’s been so completely obfuscated by the shame that I think is universally felt as a result of our collective actions.
LikeLike
Excellent explanation!!
LikeLike